American Idol Season 5

**elizabethann** · 05-03-2006, 08:12 AM

I didn't vote tonight. Not feeling too good. I barely watched the show. But here is my quick opinion:

Elliot - Didn't catch the 1st song but the 2nd song was nice. He has a great sounding voice.

Paris - Blah. I thought both songs stunk. Her speaking voice bugged me but now her singing voice is starting to.

Taylor - Awesome show! He was great bopping around in the 1st song and his second song showed how great his vocals are.

Kat - Didn't really pay attention to the 1st song, but I thought the 2nd song was great.

Chris - Renegade was awesome. Second song stunk. P.U.

Bottom 3 - Paris, Elliot and Kat
Leaving tonight - I hope it's Chris but I think it's going to be Paris

**Samantha Puppy** · 05-03-2006, 09:02 AM

I really hope Paris goes tonight. I couldn't stand her from the very beginning.

***JTM*Coco*pi*Caramel*** · 05-03-2006, 09:33 AM

Elliot: First song was Blaaahhh and the second one was better but he isnt really catching the audience and the people so I dont think he will get many votes. He is a great singer though and really talented.

Kat: I didnt like the first song, it was pitchy but the second one was great! She sounded really good but I also didnt get the floor thing

I think she is really talented and the best singer but she isnt my fav!

Chris: The first song was really well dont but not so much the second. I think he will be safe though as he has a big following and is pretty good!

Taylor: Ahhhhhhhh I love him! Both songs were well done and he was my favorite of the night! What a great performer and the second song just showed what a great singer he is! I was smiling ear to ear and clapped for his second song lol

Paris: Ok I hate he talking voice! She drives me and I never liked her. Her first song Kiss was terrible!!!!! Her second one was just a Kareoke and I think she needs to go!

Bottom 2: Paris and Elliot

Going: Paris hopefully!!!!!

**Dixieland Dancer** · 05-03-2006, 03:49 PM

Elliot wasn't his strongest. I think when he is on, he is really good. I like him a lot.

Paris, I'm tired of her and hope she's the one to leave tonight.

Chris, He sounds the same in all his songs and it gets boring. What I really hate the most is that he sings from his throat and not from his diaphram. He could be so much better if he learned voice control.

Kat, I love her voice when she isn't pitchy. Her first song last night was weak but her second song was great (minus the floor routine).

Taylor... he entertains me and I was laughing out loud with his first song and cheering him. His second song worried me at first but he pulled it off with great vocals. It's hard to do a Beatles tune and make it work (especially when it's such a popular song).

My bottom two are Paris and Elliot (sadly). I hope Paris goes and Elliot has a chance to redeem himself next week.