American Idol Season 5

[Lobodeb]

Elliott, he's so talented. He can sing anything and sound great, BUT, he lost my attention on the 2nd song. I'm not a Michael Buble fan, but I am an Elliott fan. My fear is that he's not very main-stream and he won't get the votes he needs.

Paris, ehh, nothing special. Mary J. Blidge was tough to pull off, but she did it. The only thing I didn't like, as Paula said, is that she didn't make it her own.

Chris, why is this competition still going? Just crown him the AI already. I loved both songs he sang and I'd never heard the 2nd one before.

Katherine, I wasn't crazy about the first song, I thought it was pitchy, but I loved the vocals on the 2nd song. She should really consider recording that genre when she gets her deal. I, too, didn't get the whole floor thing.

Taylor, what can I say? He's just a great performer. He may not be the strongest vocally, but heck, I'd buy a ticket to see him. His dancing is half the act!

My bottom two is also Paris and Elliott with Paris going bye-bye.

[.sarah]

Elliot - I loathe the first song he sang, though he did do a good job. The second song was nice. His voice is so beautiful and he is so humble.

Paris - eww eww eww her voice just gets worse and worse doesn't it? I thought she was awful tonight - on both songs.

Chris - I'm surprised so many people and the judges liked him! I hated both songs, sorry guys.

Katharine - Missed the first song. Second song was alright, but I still do not like her. And the raunchy floor dancing? I can do without that, thanks. Way to try to top your panty slip last week.

Taylor - GO TAYLOR GO! He rocked tonight, both songs, but especially the first!

Bottom two (are we not doing bottom three anymore?): Paris and Elliot, though I don't think Elliot deserves it.

Going home: Paris. If I call this one wrong I'll be really shocked. Her time is up.

[Lobodeb]

Way to try to top your panty slip last week.

LMAO!!!!