American Idol Season 5

[Cincy'sMom]

I will be really surprised if Chris is not one of the final 2. I'd bet on Taylor and Chris, if I were going to bet.

I guess I wouldn't be totally surprised if it came down to the 3 guys...or maybe that is just what I am hoping for. I have never been a big fan of Kat's and I think it is Paris's speaking voice that turns me off of her.

[CagneyDog]

What was the theme for tonight?

[jazzcat]

What was the theme for tonight?

They sang two songs. The first was one from the year they were born and the second was from BillBoard top 100 or something like that.

[elizabethann]

I didn't vote tonight. Not feeling too good. I barely watched the show. But here is my quick opinion:

Elliot - Didn't catch the 1st song but the 2nd song was nice. He has a great sounding voice.

Paris - Blah. I thought both songs stunk. Her speaking voice bugged me but now her singing voice is starting to.

Taylor - Awesome show! He was great bopping around in the 1st song and his second song showed how great his vocals are.

Kat - Didn't really pay attention to the 1st song, but I thought the 2nd song was great.

Chris - Renegade was awesome. Second song stunk. P.U.

Bottom 3 - Paris, Elliot and Kat
Leaving tonight - I hope it's Chris but I think it's going to be Paris

[Samantha Puppy]

I really hope Paris goes tonight. I couldn't stand her from the very beginning.

[*JTM*Coco*pi*Caramel*]

Elliot: First song was Blaaahhh and the second one was better but he isnt really catching the audience and the people so I dont think he will get many votes. He is a great singer though and really talented.

Kat: I didnt like the first song, it was pitchy but the second one was great! She sounded really good but I also didnt get the floor thing I think she is really talented and the best singer but she isnt my fav!

Chris: The first song was really well dont but not so much the second. I think he will be safe though as he has a big following and is pretty good!

Taylor: Ahhhhhhhh I love him! Both songs were well done and he was my favorite of the night! What a great performer and the second song just showed what a great singer he is! I was smiling ear to ear and clapped for his second song lol

Paris: Ok I hate he talking voice! She drives me and I never liked her. Her first song Kiss was terrible!!!!! Her second one was just a Kareoke and I think she needs to go!

Bottom 2: Paris and Elliot

Going: Paris hopefully!!!!!

[Dixieland Dancer]

Elliot wasn't his strongest. I think when he is on, he is really good. I like him a lot.

Paris, I'm tired of her and hope she's the one to leave tonight.

Chris, He sounds the same in all his songs and it gets boring. What I really hate the most is that he sings from his throat and not from his diaphram. He could be so much better if he learned voice control.

Kat, I love her voice when she isn't pitchy. Her first song last night was weak but her second song was great (minus the floor routine).

Taylor... he entertains me and I was laughing out loud with his first song and cheering him. His second song worried me at first but he pulled it off with great vocals. It's hard to do a Beatles tune and make it work (especially when it's such a popular song).

My bottom two are Paris and Elliot (sadly). I hope Paris goes and Elliot has a chance to redeem himself next week.

[jazzcat]

Elliott - He's my favorite but I didn't think he was at his best tonight. His first song was good but not magical and I just don't like the second song he sang. He sang it fine but it is a boring song that I turn away from when I hear it on the radio. On that note I really hope he stays. I called and got through for him about 10 times.

Chris - I thought his first song was great - loved it when I was young - but I didn't care for his second song. He really bleats like a goat when he sings.

Katherine - I thought she butchered the first song and didn't care for how she performed the second but she did sing it better. I just don't like her attitude or something. She really puts me off.

Taylor - I thought his first song was great but I just hate that second song he sang and his version sounded like a funeral march to me.

Paris - She did better on Kiss than I imagined but I'm very tired of her. Hope she's the one that goes and not Elliott!

[Lobodeb]

Elliott, he's so talented. He can sing anything and sound great, BUT, he lost my attention on the 2nd song. I'm not a Michael Buble fan, but I am an Elliott fan. My fear is that he's not very main-stream and he won't get the votes he needs.

Paris, ehh, nothing special. Mary J. Blidge was tough to pull off, but she did it. The only thing I didn't like, as Paula said, is that she didn't make it her own.

Chris, why is this competition still going? Just crown him the AI already. I loved both songs he sang and I'd never heard the 2nd one before.

Katherine, I wasn't crazy about the first song, I thought it was pitchy, but I loved the vocals on the 2nd song. She should really consider recording that genre when she gets her deal. I, too, didn't get the whole floor thing.

Taylor, what can I say? He's just a great performer. He may not be the strongest vocally, but heck, I'd buy a ticket to see him. His dancing is half the act!

My bottom two is also Paris and Elliott with Paris going bye-bye.

[.sarah]

Elliot - I loathe the first song he sang, though he did do a good job. The second song was nice. His voice is so beautiful and he is so humble.

Paris - eww eww eww her voice just gets worse and worse doesn't it? I thought she was awful tonight - on both songs.

Chris - I'm surprised so many people and the judges liked him! I hated both songs, sorry guys.

Katharine - Missed the first song. Second song was alright, but I still do not like her. And the raunchy floor dancing? I can do without that, thanks. Way to try to top your panty slip last week.

Taylor - GO TAYLOR GO! He rocked tonight, both songs, but especially the first!

Bottom two (are we not doing bottom three anymore?): Paris and Elliot, though I don't think Elliot deserves it.

Going home: Paris. If I call this one wrong I'll be really shocked. Her time is up.

[Lobodeb]

Way to try to top your panty slip last week.

LMAO!!!!