American Idol Season 5

[jazzcat]

Elliott is the man! I thought he did great and so did Chris.

I thought the judges were kind of hard on Katherine. I don't really care for her, like .sarah it's an attitude thing, but she wasn't that bad tonight.

Please, can Kellie leave now!?!

[*JTM*Coco*pi*Caramel*]

Katherine-I usually don't care to much about her either but I thought she did really good tonight! For like the first time I really enjoyed her but the judges didnt

Elliot- Did really well I thought, he is a true idol but not many ppl seem to care for him. My Mom loveeees him!

Kelly- I use to love her but she isnt progressing, she can't get out of her comfort zone and isnt able to do other styles of music. I think her time has come.

Taylor- I just love him, he did alright tonight, but just alright.

Paris- I don't like her at all and never have. Her performance was alright I guess but it was to old for her.

Chris- I never really bothered with him but man did he do good tonight Omg I just loved his performance and especially after the past couple of weeks, this pulls him out of danger I think! Plus he sang my fav song and Brian Adams is Canadian

Bottom 3:
Paris (will go)
Kelly (should go by her performances)
Katherine

[christa]

Oh WOW!!! I think Chris was singing that love song to me, LOL . . . wait, I'm married, oh yeah . . . that's right . . . so is he . . . LOLOLOL . . . guess he IS good! Shew, was he EVER good last night!!! Okay, enough about Chris.

Kat: She's really beautiful but I think Randy & the judges were right about the song being too big for her. She *tried* but I don't think she really pulled it off. She has an awesome voice but I wish that she'd back it down a bit. Not try quite that hard.

Elliot: He is such a sweetie and I thought he did fantastic tonight! I really hope he stays!!! He has such a unique voice! I just love listening to him! I would be really interested to see what kind of an album he would come out with!

Kellie: Poor girl . . . she just hasn't been doing well. Last night was the worst yet. Unless she just has a crazy fan base, I can't see her going much further after that. (that and she's currently on "votefortheworst.com") . . . maybe that's why she's still hanging in there.

Taylor: I always love Taylor . . . for some reason, I just love his voice. Maybe it's my bluegrass/country/KY roots. I don't know. I just love his southern feel. I enjoyed his performance tonight, although it wasn't my favorite. I still can't imagine him being in the bottom 3.

Paris: I haven't liked her from the beginning. I like her speaking voice, I hate her singing voice. She tries to sound like a 40 year old and she looks like a 15 year old. Paris - your time is coming.

The bottom 3 will be . . . Paris, Kellie & Kat.

I hope that Kellie or Paris goes tonight. Either would be fine with me.