American Idol Season 5

[.sarah]

Katharine - Ehh, she's alright. I've never really liked her, but I can understand why other people do. I think it's her attitude that has made me dislike her, not her voice.

Elliot - He deserves to win this. He has the best voice by a mile.

Kellie - Yeah ... that sucked.

Taylor - He was alright. The beginning was pitchy, but he got better towards the end and really made the song.

Paris - She did good, but not good enough.

Chris - He rocked again, finally! After a few weeks of thinking he's gone downhill, I'm really glad to see him do a good performance again!

Bottom three - Kellie, Paris, and Katharine.

Going home - I think Paris will go, but Kellie is the one who should go. She's the only one left who doesn't have a powerful voice.

[jazzcat]

Elliott is the man! I thought he did great and so did Chris.

I thought the judges were kind of hard on Katherine. I don't really care for her, like .sarah it's an attitude thing, but she wasn't that bad tonight.

Please, can Kellie leave now!?!

[*JTM*Coco*pi*Caramel*]

Katherine-I usually don't care to much about her either but I thought she did really good tonight! For like the first time I really enjoyed her but the judges didnt

Elliot- Did really well I thought, he is a true idol but not many ppl seem to care for him. My Mom loveeees him!

Kelly- I use to love her but she isnt progressing, she can't get out of her comfort zone and isnt able to do other styles of music. I think her time has come.

Taylor- I just love him, he did alright tonight, but just alright.

Paris- I don't like her at all and never have. Her performance was alright I guess but it was to old for her.

Chris- I never really bothered with him but man did he do good tonight Omg I just loved his performance and especially after the past couple of weeks, this pulls him out of danger I think! Plus he sang my fav song and Brian Adams is Canadian

Bottom 3:
Paris (will go)
Kelly (should go by her performances)
Katherine

[christa]

Oh WOW!!! I think Chris was singing that love song to me, LOL . . . wait, I'm married, oh yeah . . . that's right . . . so is he . . . LOLOLOL . . . guess he IS good! Shew, was he EVER good last night!!! Okay, enough about Chris.

Kat: She's really beautiful but I think Randy & the judges were right about the song being too big for her. She *tried* but I don't think she really pulled it off. She has an awesome voice but I wish that she'd back it down a bit. Not try quite that hard.

Elliot: He is such a sweetie and I thought he did fantastic tonight! I really hope he stays!!! He has such a unique voice! I just love listening to him! I would be really interested to see what kind of an album he would come out with!

Kellie: Poor girl . . . she just hasn't been doing well. Last night was the worst yet. Unless she just has a crazy fan base, I can't see her going much further after that. (that and she's currently on "votefortheworst.com") . . . maybe that's why she's still hanging in there.

Taylor: I always love Taylor . . . for some reason, I just love his voice. Maybe it's my bluegrass/country/KY roots. I don't know. I just love his southern feel. I enjoyed his performance tonight, although it wasn't my favorite. I still can't imagine him being in the bottom 3.

Paris: I haven't liked her from the beginning. I like her speaking voice, I hate her singing voice. She tries to sound like a 40 year old and she looks like a 15 year old. Paris - your time is coming.

The bottom 3 will be . . . Paris, Kellie & Kat.

I hope that Kellie or Paris goes tonight. Either would be fine with me.

[Dixieland Dancer]

My bottom three picks are: Kelli (I think she should go tonight), Paris and Taylor (sadly because I like Him).

I did not agree with the judges about Katherine. I thought she sounded good and I did not compare her to Whitney Houston. I just enjoyed her perfomance.

Kelli was very weak. Chris did a very good job but Elliot was the best. It even brought Paula Abdul to tears (which had me in tears ).

[krazyaboutkatz]

Chris is still my favorite and I thought that he performed very well last night. I tried to vote for him but couldn't get through and then I forgot to try again.

My bottom 3 picks are Kellie, Taylor, and Paris. Even though I like Kellie's personality, her voice just isn't strong enough to win this competition. It's time for her to go.

[Felix]

Bye Bye Pickler

[christa]

Well, I hated to see Kellie go but I think she was definitely in line next. I mean, at this point, everyone is great. They all have star potential IMO. There can only be ONE though . . .

Kellie's performance last night was pretty terrible . . . I think she'd do fine sticking with country/bluegrass. Who knows.

What is the theme for next week? Did they ever say??? I missed that part!

[elizabethann]

Well, I hated to see Kellie go but I think she was definitely in line next. I mean, at this point, everyone is great. They all have star potential IMO. There can only be ONE though . . .

Kellie's performance last night was pretty terrible . . . I think she'd do fine sticking with country/bluegrass. Who knows.

What is the theme for next week? Did they ever say??? I missed that part!

Somebody on the AI board said they'll be singing 2 songs. One will be billboard and the other is a song from the year they were born.

[Roxyluvsme13]

I wanted Paris to go, but oh well. Kellie didn't do so hot last night.

[flamepony12]

I'm so glad Kellie and Ace are gone. Hopefully Taylor will be next.

[rosethecopycat]

Elliot - He deserves to win this. He has the best voice by a mile.

Right on.

[elizabethann]

Don't forget to watch AI tonight! I'm torn....Red Sox vs. Yankee's or AI? Luckily, the game may be rained out so I'll be able to watch AI!

[caseysmom]

Yeah we have game 5 of our kings vs. spurs tonight and its 2 to 2 so its a big game...I will be doing a lot of flipping of channels.

[christa]

Well???

I have no idea how it will go tomorrow.

Elliott: I missed his first song. Didn't even see the recap so I'm not even sure what it was. Liked the second song though . . . I really like his voice and when he makes it BIG, it's so great! I think he'll do great, even if he doesn't make it as the AI.

Paris: I don't know what it is about her, I just don't like her voice. I think it's how her speaking voice is so baby-fied and her singing voice sounds like she's a 50 year old woman, you know? I really wish she'd try to sound YOUNGER when she sings. I think that if she did, I'd like her a whole lot more because I LOVE her personality, I just hate her singing voice.

Chris: IMO, Chris can do no wrong. I just can't imagine him getting voted out . . . but he was in the bottom 2 that one time . . . I thought he did GREAT tonight though!!! Especially that first song! He's so hot!

Kat: The first song was okay . . . Vocally, the second song was great. But that thing she did on the floor was kind of gross. Looked raunchy a few times there, if you know what I mean! Was I missing something?

Taylor: I LOVED Taylor tonight! Wow! He was really on fire! Really loved his first song and then I thought that vocally, his second song was outstanding. I had no idea that he could sing that well! LOL

I *think* the bottom 2 will be Paris & Elliott . . .

If I have to choose, I hope that Paris goes.