American Idol Season 5

[RobiLee]

I hadn't really been that impressed with Elliot previously, but I thought he did great this week.


Did anyone else think Kelly looked a little like Lita Ford at the beginning of her song? I think it was the hair.
(Does anyone else remeber Lita Ford?)

That's so funny, Amy. I remember her and actually heard one of her songs the other day on a music channel. Kellie did look a bit like her.

I hated to see Bucky go, but I do think it was time. At this point I hate to see anyone go. It makes me sad . I was really sweating it out that Elliot was in the bottom three. I'm a big fan of his. I'm going to have to place alot of votes for him next week

My top three are Elliot, Taylor and Chris. I think Chris is going to win.

[rosethecopycat]

American Songbook.

Chris did well. Albiet a safe song.

Paris, lots of style.

Taylor. That was not a call from the American Songbook (standard). That was a 50's song.

Elliot. That was a poor choice of song.

Better songs for Elliot:

Lush Life
Nature Boy
My Old Flame
My Romance
Old Folks
Tangerine
Angel Eyes
I've Got the World on a String
Who Can I Turn To
A Fine Romance
Beyond the Sea


Kellie. The most glaring error in her performance, only Paula picked it up!
SHE GOT AHEAD OF THE MUSIC (by at least 2 beats) and clashed with the chord changes!


Ace. Pretty much bad. Out of tune.


Katherine. Great sense of style, good ability in carrying a song. First time time she's impressed me at all.



MY Bottom 3:

Ace, Kellie, Taylor


Husband's bottom 3:

Ace, Kellie, Elliot

[elizabethann]

AAAGGHHH!!! I fell asleep and missed Chris & Paris, so I can't tell you what I thought of them. But as for the rest:

Taylor: I thought he did really good. He just makes the crowd go wild and he's a great performer.

Elliot: I actually missed some of his singing but what I did hear, I sort of liked.

Kellie: Ugh. That was awful. But I wouldn't want her to leave just yet because she's been pretty good throughout the whole competition.

Ace: I'm sorry to say I liked it. But what's with the new look? And did you hear Simon give him a positive review? I almost passed out (along with Ace).

Katherine: Wow! That was awesome!

I voted once for Taylor and once for Katherine.

My bottom 3: Eliott (because I don't think his voice is anything special - though I do think he seems like a great guy), Ace (because I don't think he's been good throughout the whole competition) and Paris (just because I don't think she's as good as some of the others).

I hope i don't fall asleep tonight!

[christa]

I MISSED THE SHOW LAST NIGHT!

From what I hear, it was the best so far . . . which is a good thing . . . seems like it hasn't been all that good up until now, so I'm glad that they're at least improving.

I did catch Kellie's performance . . . poor girl and I did see Ace's new dooooooooooo . . . . or whatever that is LOL . . . what are the stylist on that show thinking anyway? They have really embarrassed some of them this year! With all the makeup . . . dressing Taylor that one week like a 19 year old preppy, and now the slicked back look for Ace? Ugh! Not to mention "the many faces of paris" . . . I guess that's showbiz.

Anyway . . . can't wait to watch tonight . . . just wish I had an opinion based on what happened last night. Can't believe I missed it!

[Dixieland Dancer]

I MISSED THE SHOW LAST NIGHT!

Can't believe I missed it!

So did I. Someone knocked on our door 10 minutes before the show and didn't leave until almost 2 hours later. They were only suppose to stop and pick something up.

From past performances, I will not be upset if it is Ace that leaves (no matter how good he did last night).

[.sarah]

I missed the show last night too. I was hoping the official website would have clips up but they don't yet.

I also hope that Ace leaves, judging on past performances. I do not like him one bit, never have.

[*JTM*Coco*pi*Caramel*]

Taylor: I just love him! What a performer and he did well!

Kellie: She did bad and knew it but she is usually really good!

Paris: She did well but nothing special for me.

Ace: He did better than usual but I disagree with Simon the new look was bad

Chris: Good change for him and was alright.

Elliot: It was alright and I like him but he doesnt seem to be really popular.

Katherine: She did excellent, she was the best of the night!

My bottom three:
Ace (who I want to go badly!)
Paris
Chris (just because I like Elliot to much to put him in the bottom three )