American Idol Season 5

[Daisy and Delilah]

I am still angry that Mandesa left......

I'm with you Flatcoatluver. I can't get over the fact that Mandesa is gone. The show just isn't the same. I did think they all had their best night this week so far. Unlike most people, I think Ace was the best he's done yet. I haven't been impressed with him at all in the past. He is a cutie pie though For some reason, I love Elliot. When he goes I'll be very sad. I was also sad to see Bucky go, especially after hearing his Dad talk about him. I think it will come down to Kellie and Chris at the end and I think Chris is probably going to win

[.sarah]

I was upset that Bucky left last night. If we are basing it on performances from the night before, which it seems like America is doing, then I don't understand why Bucky left. If we are basing it on talent then Bucky and a few others should have gone long ago. I think Ace was far worse than Bucky though, and he should have gone last night. His huge ego is on my last nerve, too. But I personally like Bucky's personality, though a lot of people on message boards have been saying they can't understand him. I can understand everything he says lol. His accent is pretty normal around here

I was really upset to see Elliot in the bottom 3. He is my favorite. He is one of the few left that actually has talent, and in my opinion is the only one left who is still grounded. (Well Taylor seems pretty grounded too.) And his 'life story' ... how sweet! I love that he can cry in front of people and not be ashamed.

I love Chris as well but I don't think he has been good the past few weeks. And the eyeliner was a huge turnoff. Still love his smile, though

I really enjoyed Taylor's performance. I was up getting money ready for the pizza guy and I just started dancing! I love that song!

I personally thought that Katharine was awful. It sounded like she was sort of screaming, and she sounded a little sharp to me.

Kellie did pretty good but she is getting on my nerves. Oh, and nice going mentioning the "snot rag"

I guess I am one of the few who enjoyed Paris' performance. I liked the look too, thought it fit the song and the theme.

[rosethecopycat]

I just caught up.


I was worried about Taylor. But I'm glad to see that you all still are rooting for him. After his clumsiness, and doing that lousy, bubblegum rock Queen song, I figured he was doomed.

I loved Elliot. That was a very difficult song, especially compared to what Ace sang.

Ace, well, everyone has seemed to turn on him. At the beginning of this thread he surely was the pretty, golden boy. I never liked him.

Bucky, it doesn't really matter if he or Ace went first, they both are going to go. Still, Mandisa should still be sitting there.

Comparing Paris to Katherine. Paris' high belt note was much clearer than Katherine's.

Chris has been a bit disappointing lately, I can't put my finger on it, he sure can sing. Maybe it's his selection.

Kelly, I didn't dig it.


on to Rod Stewart slaughtering the American Songbook...