American Idol Season 5

[Dixieland Dancer]

Of all the shows to date, I thought last nights was the best. At first when I heard they would have to sing Queens songs, I thought that will never work but they all did good!

This is the first week I don't have a definite pick to be voted off. If I was pressed, it would be Ace. My favorite performance this week was Taylor. He jumped around perhaps a bit more than he needed to but his vocals and style for the song he sang were excellent!

[Samantha Puppy]

What is next week's theme supposed to be?

[krazyaboutkatz]

I'm a huge rock fan so I really enjoyed last nights "Queen Theme". I thought that most of them performed very well but I think that Ace was the worst and really needs to go. I also agree that Bucky is way out of his league and should be voted off very soon. Chris is still my favorite and he also performed well but I wish that he had picked a better song to perform because this could've been his night to really shine. I voted for him again.

[RedHedd]

Loved them all so it was hard to pick who to vote for .... so I voted for all of them, except I couldn't get through for the longest time for Bucky, Katharine or Paris. I LOVED Kellie's look and today on the radio I heard the men loved her too Elliot was a bit rough for me, and Taylor is back to being Taylor, which I'm starting to get tired of.

My bottom three: Ace, Bucky and Elliot, with Ace going home (please).

[joanofark]

I hope Ace leaves!! TONIGHT!!!!!

[joanofark]

IF YOU HAVN'T SEEN IT YET DON'T READ THIS POST!!!!!!!!!!!!





























I can't beileve he's gone!! Bucky was good last night!! UHG! Ace should have got the boot!!! I think Elliot needs to stop the pity stories...

[RedHedd]

I can't beileve he's gone!! Bucky was good last night!! UHG! Ace should have got the boot!!! I think Elliot needs to stop the pity stories...

I always check the messages boards before the results show comes on because I'm always watching Lost when the results show is on. I agree, Bucky was good last night; Ace should have been the one to go home. too bad. At least we know he'll be on tour with the top ten. This is the first time I jsut might buy tickets to their show!

[cali]

Bucky is gone? aww I dont much like him but I thought he was good last night lol I really liked Ace last night, its the just the "we will rock you" line that was too weak, I can breath easy knowing he did not get the boot lol I would have prefered elliot to be gone though after last nights show, out of the 3 I thought Elliots was by far the worst lol

[anna_66]

out of the 3 I thought Elliots was by far the worst lol

Really? I personally thought Elliott was the best out of all of them last night.
I can't believe he was even in the bottom three.


Like Simon said, Ace should have been the one going home not Bucky. I knew he wouldn't win, but I just wasn't ready for him to go home yet. He did a great job on Fat Bottom Girls

[Lobodeb]

Ace should have gone, not Bucky.

[elizabethann]

Ace should have gone, not Bucky.

Ditto.

[pitc9]

Anna, I'm with you! Elliot sounded the best out of the bottom 3!
OMG! I had to turn the station when he sang last night, just like I did on Tuesday night when he... urr... mmm... TRIED to sing! Oh Ace needs to go!!

[Lobodeb]

Oh, and what's with all the makeup that Chris and Ace were wearing!? Good grief! They looked terrible.

[Samantha Puppy]

Oh, and what's with all the makeup that Chris and Ace were wearing!? Good grief! They looked terrible.

My husband and I were wondering the same thing. He said, "Hey @$$holes, just because Freddie Mercury liked wearing make-up doesn't mean you have to too!" LOL

[Roxyluvsme13]

Ace should have gone...but Honestly, I think the worst person based on songs was Paris.