American Idol Season 5

[pnance]

Mandesa was one of my favorite. I agree she did bad last night but I think others should have gone first. I have to agree that Queen songs are going to really difficult for some of them.

[.sarah]

Funny, this season started out really good. Everyone seemed so talented. Lately, everyone is just "ok" and I'm getting pretty bored with the show.

Though I don't think it's fair that Bucky, Kellie, and Ace have stuck around while Lisa and Mandisa went home. They are both far more talented then the other three ever will be.

[Flatcoatluver]

I am so angry!! Mandesa was my favorite now who am i gonna vote for next week?

[nicanc724]

i started watching AI but i haven't seen the last couple of episodes.....

[Daisy and Delilah]

Mandisa may be gone from Idol but I expect to see great things from her in the future. What a beautiful, gracious, lady she is. Good luck Mandisa!!

[elizabethann]

Mandisa may be gone from Idol but I expect to see great things from her in the future. What a beautiful, gracious, lady she is. Good luck Mandisa!!

I agree. She my be the new Aretha Franklin or Whitney Houston.

[christa]

Wow . . . I just am in such shock about the results. I mean, she was horrible and everything, totally butchered that S. Twain song, but I really thought she'd have more of a fan base than that. She's been awesome up until now, she can sing circles around just about anyone in the competition. Not saying she's my fav . . . Just that she shouldn't have gone - especially before bucky . . . Wow . . .

I'm sure that this won't be the end for her though . . . she's probably already been signed . . . which is probably the best thing for her.