American Idol Season 5

[Felix]

The performances I enjoyed tonight were...of course Chris I LOVE you Chris ,Elliot,and although im not pickles biggest fan I think she done ok tonight.The rest were kinda boring for me.

[rosethecopycat]

Tonight was interesting. The people I think need to go, did pretty well. Namely, Ace, Bucky and Pickler.

I think the ones who are vulnerable are: Taylor, Mandisa, and Elliot.
My husband thinks that it's: Paris, Taylor, and Bucky.


I'm learning that the general population isn't as fond of Elliot and Mandisa as we are.

[Lobodeb]

Here I go again.

Taylor: hmmmm, nothing special. A little disappointed.

Mandisa: Shania Twain? Nah, didn't work for me.

Ace: Not bad, actually.

Elliot: I liked it. I liked the way he made it his own.

Kellie: I thought she did well. I didn't like how she said town, though.

Paris: Difficult song to sing, but very pitchy.

Chris: WILL YOU MARRY ME? It was nice to see something different. I was hoping that he'd sing that song by Marc Chestnut, Don't Want To Close My Eyes. Aerosmith also did it.

Katherine: Nothing special.

Bucky: Ummm, I didn't understand a word he said.

My bottom 3: Mandisa, Ace and Bucky.

Time for Bucky to go.

[rosethecopycat]

Nice calls, Lobodeb.

Wouldn't it be ironic if Bucky left on Country night?

[elizabethann]

My turn! My turn!


Taylor: Ouch...he was bad.

Mandisa: Double ouch...stick to gospel.

Ace: Very surprising..did okay AND he didn't hog the camera with his puppy dog eyes.

Elliot: I liked it too.

Kellie: Awesome...but that's her forte.

Paris: Didn't do anything for me.

Chris: It was okay...nothing special.

Katherine: I think I switched channels and missed her whole performance so I can't critique it.

Bucky: I thought he was good.

Based on last nights performance, my bottom 3 would be:

Mandissa, Bucky and this one hurts me....Taylor.

But I think it's time for Bucky to go because he hasn't been 100% on his "game" throughout the competition.

[christa]

Taylor: Living so close to WV, I LOVED the song, loved him singing it. He's always one of my favs.

Mandisa: She REALLY should have chose more wisely. I think *country nite* is gonna hurt Miss Mandisa!

Ace: Loved it! I think this will get Ace out of the bottom 3 . . . this week anyway. I hope he keeps this up.

Elliot: Loved it! I thought it was a great vocal! He has such an interesting range!

Kellie: She has a really great country voice (duh) . . . but I REALLY wish she'd put some EXPRESSION on her cute little face while she sings!!! She has such a blank look!!!

Paris: Well, we know that she would never sing country so . . . I guess I'll let her off the hook . . . *gag* . . . sorry Paris . . . better luck next week and hope this didn't hurt you too much. BTW, Simon was WAY off base with his remarks! He was just trying to get a rise out of Paula!

Chris: I LOVED it!!! He is so sexy & to see him singing that slow song . . . he's always been my FAV . . . no doubts now!

Katherine: Simon was right . . . that was wierd.

Bucky: I thought it was funny when Kenny Rogers told him that it was important to annunciate every word in a song like that and then even *I* couldn't understand him and I've heard that song a million times.

My bottom three: Mandisa, Paris, Bucky

Who do I think deserves to GO? Bucky

Bye bye Bucky.

Hopefully it won't be a total upset

[joanofark]

Chris and Paris were the BEST!!

Katherine was ok.

Kellie shined!!

I loved the song Taylor did! but wasn't his best...

Mandisa, Elliot, Ace, and Bucky.-- ick!

[krazyaboutkatz]

I think that Taylor,Mandisa, and Paris weren't good at all.

Even though I don't like country, I thought that Kelly, Chris, Elliot, and Ace were pretty good.

Bucky was just okay and I couldn't understand a thing he said either.

Katherine sang well but she did pick a weird song.

I think that Mandisa,Bucky, and Paris will be in the bottom three. I also agree that Bucky should go but he probably won't this week because of all of the country fans.

[RedHedd]

Taylor: Ouch...he was bad. Where's the REAL Taylor?

Mandisa: Didn't do it for me and who put her in STRIPES! Yipes!

Ace: Buh-bye, Ace. It's time to go.

Elliot: What a surprise! I liked it a lot.

Kellie: Cute. I knew she'd do well this week.

Paris: FINALLY, she's looking like a star and not a 9 year old. I liked her singing too.

Chris: Loved it!

Katherine: Voted for her too.

Bucky: I thought he was good.

Based on last night's performance, my bottom 3 would be:

Ace, Mandisa and Taylor.

It's time for Ace to go

[.sarah]

Taylor - What was that? That performance left me with a blank look on my face.

Mandisa - Ruined a very neat song. There are plenty of country songs that she could have done that would have fit her voice better.

Elliot - Not bad, but still not as good as I thought he'd be.

Chris - Pretty good, but could've done better. Song choice was good.

Kellie - She didn't "wow" me but she was most definetly the best of the night.

Bucky - I thought he was good. I could understand what he was saying but then again I love that song, so that could be why.

Katharine - Wow, she is really starting to act cocky. Total turnoff. Vocals - they were pretty good ... I hate that song though.

Paris - Not bad, but not good either.

Ace - Much better than I expected, but I still can't stand the guy. He's way too into himself.

Bottom three - Taylor, Mandisa, and Katharine, Bucky or Ace (no I can't decide ... everyone pretty much sucked equally last night!!).

Going home - ??? I really can't decide who I think is going home tonight. I HOPE it's Ace, but I think he stepped it up a notch last night and will be staying.

[jazzcat]

I didn't just love anyone last night (I really don't like country music) but I think it's way past time for Bucky to go. I hope Kellie Pickler isn't far behind.

Sorry, but like I said I REALLY don't like country music.

Chris and Elliot were about the only ones I didn't have to fast forward through.