American Idol Season 5

**CagneyDog** · 03-29-2006, 09:25 PM

Katherine is in the BOTTOM THREE

Oh my god.

I didn't think that would ever happen

**christa** · 03-29-2006, 09:48 PM

Originally Posted by CagneyDog

Oh my god.

I didn't think that would ever happen

I was sooooooo happy that Katherine was in the bottom 3!!! They give that girl way too much credit . . . saying last night that she sounded better than Christina? OMG! I'm glad that Simon took it back tonight! It must really sound different on TV! I mean, she's OK but they were really pushing her and I didn't think she was all that great. Anyway, maybe tonight will give her a wakeup call . . . now she won't think of herself as a shoe-in.

**CagneyDog** · 03-29-2006, 09:59 PM

Originally Posted by christa

I was sooooooo happy that Katherine was in the bottom 3!!! They give that girl way too much credit . . . saying last night that she sounded better than Christina? OMG! I'm glad that Simon took it back tonight! It must really sound different on TV! I mean, she's OK but they were really pushing her and I didn't think she was all that great. Anyway, maybe tonight will give her a wakeup call . . . now she won't think of herself as a shoe-in.

I think she is a good singer but she is -wayyyyy- to stuck up.

Man, the judges were just awful last night.

**christa** · 03-29-2006, 10:10 PM

Originally Posted by CagneyDog

I think she is a good singer but she is -wayyyyy- to stuck up.

Man, the judges were just awful last night.

Yeah, that's what I'm saying . . . she needed a wake up call. Now she knows that just because the judges want her in (that's what it seems) . . . that's not how the game goes.

The judges were moody last night but to be honest, they didn't have much to work with. Maybe everyone just had their nerves turned on high last night or something. There wasn't really one person that blew me away last night, which was a first. I hope next week is better!

**CagneyDog** · 03-29-2006, 10:14 PM

The judges were moody last night but to be honest, they didn't have much to work with. Maybe everyone just had their nerves turned on high last night or something. There wasn't really one person that blew me away last night, which was a first. I hope next week is better!

I agree last night was bad, I actually shut it off for awhile. There wasn't anyone exceptional, but I did like Mandisa's performence. She is probably my favorite.
I thought Lisa and Chris had really bad peformences. Lisa just sounded awful and I thought Chris's was a bit to harsh (but that's probably just me)