American Idol Season 5

[Lobodeb]

My turn!!!

Lisa: Next to go. That was terrible.

Taylor: I liked it. It was nice to hear him sing and not do the whole "head tilt, let the music move you" bit. Granted I like him for that. I thought it was a nice change.

Bucky: I actually liked it. Not a vocally challenging song, but he sang it well.

Chris: A little too loud for me. I would have like to hear him sing a slower Creed song. He still did good though.

Kellie: There were so many better songs she could have picked. I wasn't impressed. She's starting to sound nasaly to me.

Ace: Does anyone watch Amateur Night at the Appolo? Can you say WAP WAP!! That was painful. Cute or not, that was aweful.

Mandesa: I felt like she was oversinging. Wasn't feeling the whole gospel thing, and I like gospel music.

Paris: YOU GO GIRL!! I loved her performance. If Simon thinks 17 year old girls don't dance that way, he's obviously out of touch. I've seen 10 year old girls dance that way.

Katherine: Sorry, I didn't like it.

Elliot: Ok, nothing special.

Did I forget anyone?

My bottom 3: Lisa, Kellie and Mandesa

My vote to go: Lisa

[RedHedd]

Lisa: Wasn't too bad.

Taylor: I liked it. It was nice to hear him sing and not do his Joe Cocker jerky moves.

Bucky: I liked it - I like that song and there's something about him I like too, but I don't think he'll last too much longer; his vocals aren't strong enough.

Chris: Simon was right. I love his performances, but I need to see something different.

Kellie: I like her, just wish she would sing something more challenging to show some range.

Ace: He always looks absolutely terrified to be up on stage. He may be a good singer, but he has to get over his nervousness if he wants to last much longer.

Mandisa: I didn't like that song at all. It sounded out of tune or something. I didn't vote for her at all this week.

Paris: Was the best of the night.

Katherine: Sounded way too sharp during the whole song. I was amazed the judges praised her the way they did. She had an off night to my ears last night, but I voted for her anyway.

Elliot: He bugs me - don't know what it is. Nice voice; awful teeth, bad hair.

Did I forget anyone?

My bottom 3: Bucky, Ace, Lisa.

My vote to go: Probably Bucky, but could be any of my bottom three.

[Lobodeb]

Lisa: Wasn't too bad.

Taylor: I liked it. It was nice to hear him sing and not do his Joe Cocker jerky moves.

Bucky: I liked it - I like that song and there's something about him I like too, but I don't think he'll last too much longer; his vocals aren't strong enough.

Chris: Simon was right. I love his performances, but I need to see something different.

Kellie: I like her, just wish she would sing something more challenging to show some range.

Ace: He always looks absolutely terrified to be up on stage. He may be a good singer, but he has to get over his nervousness if he wants to last much longer.

Mandisa: I didn't like that song at all. It sounded out of tune or something. I didn't vote for her at all this week.

Paris: Was the best of the night.

Katherine: Sounded way too sharp during the whole song. I was amazed the judges praised her the way they did. She had an off night to my ears last night, but I voted for her anyway.

Elliot: He bugs me - don't know what it is. Nice voice; awful teeth, bad hair.

Did I forget anyone?

My bottom 3: Bucky, Ace, Lisa.

My vote to go: Probably Bucky, but could be any of my bottom three.

PLAGERISM!!!! j/k

[RedHedd]

PLAGERISM!!!! j/k

Actually just laziness!

[cali]

I am obviously in minority here but I like Ace lol he does tend to look awful nervus on stage though.

Lisa-I liked it, I did not thing it was that bad.

Kellie-I liked it lol I love the song so I really enjoyed the preformance, I am rooting for her to be in the top 3

Taylor-I really like him, and last nights vocals were really good, but he is loosing his inviduality, his crazyness is his appeal and last night he blended right in with everyone else.

Bucky-how in heavens name he even got into the top 12 over gedeon is beyond me, I will be happy when he's gone.

Elliot-good singer but he looks like a monkey and it bugs me lol

Mandisa-fabulous singer, but lasts night preformace was BAD lol

Katherine-sorry never liked her from the start her voice is so annoying.

Ace-good singer, needs to relax

Chris-I really like him but we need a break from the hard rock type songs lol

Paris-LOVE her lol her and Kellie are my favorites, her voice is so strong, its great.

my picks for bottom 3:

Mandisa, Bucky, Elliot

[joanofark]

Elliot-good singer but he looks like a monkey and it bugs me lol

*Snort**Raises hand* lol, I agree

[Roxyluvsme13]

Katherine is in the BOTTOM THREE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Me=Total Shock..about to die.
Ace is in the bottom 3, too though .

[CagneyDog]

Katherine is in the BOTTOM THREE

Oh my god.
I didn't think that would ever happen

[Felix]

First Of all Id like to say my sweetie Chris is SAFE again tonight.Yay! Go Chris Go!

I enjoyed Shakira's performance,it was awsome!

I can't believe Katherine was in the bottom three ,I thought for sure it was going to be Bucky in her place.

I suspected that Lisa was the next to go.

[christa]

Oh my god.
I didn't think that would ever happen

I was sooooooo happy that Katherine was in the bottom 3!!! They give that girl way too much credit . . . saying last night that she sounded better than Christina? OMG! I'm glad that Simon took it back tonight! It must really sound different on TV! I mean, she's OK but they were really pushing her and I didn't think she was all that great. Anyway, maybe tonight will give her a wakeup call . . . now she won't think of herself as a shoe-in.

[CagneyDog]

I was sooooooo happy that Katherine was in the bottom 3!!! They give that girl way too much credit . . . saying last night that she sounded better than Christina? OMG! I'm glad that Simon took it back tonight! It must really sound different on TV! I mean, she's OK but they were really pushing her and I didn't think she was all that great. Anyway, maybe tonight will give her a wakeup call . . . now she won't think of herself as a shoe-in.

I think she is a good singer but she is -wayyyyy- to stuck up.

Man, the judges were just awful last night.

[christa]

I think she is a good singer but she is -wayyyyy- to stuck up.

Man, the judges were just awful last night.

Yeah, that's what I'm saying . . . she needed a wake up call. Now she knows that just because the judges want her in (that's what it seems) . . . that's not how the game goes.

The judges were moody last night but to be honest, they didn't have much to work with. Maybe everyone just had their nerves turned on high last night or something. There wasn't really one person that blew me away last night, which was a first. I hope next week is better!

[CagneyDog]

The judges were moody last night but to be honest, they didn't have much to work with. Maybe everyone just had their nerves turned on high last night or something. There wasn't really one person that blew me away last night, which was a first. I hope next week is better!

I agree last night was bad, I actually shut it off for awhile. There wasn't anyone exceptional, but I did like Mandisa's performence. She is probably my favorite.
I thought Lisa and Chris had really bad peformences. Lisa just sounded awful and I thought Chris's was a bit to harsh (but that's probably just me)

[Roxyluvsme13]

Just curious if anybody heard the Kellie Pickler quote?
She didn't actually say this but someone said she would say:
"How can I sing a song that's not even been written yet?"
(21st century theme... )

ETA:Chicken Little is going to be on Fox News tonight.

[Lobodeb]

Katherine needed to be in the bottom 3. She wasn't good. I'm glad she didn't go, though. Shed is a good singer, just had a bad night.

Bye Lisa!

I'm anxious to see how Chris can rock out a country song next week. This is Kellie's and Bucky's time to shine.