American Idol Season 5

[CagneyDog]

Oh, yeah, I forgot to mention Mandisa.
She's probably my favorite out of all of them. She just seems so original and comfortable with being herself.

[RobiLee]

I'm disappointed that Melissa got kicked off. I like her personality and I like her voice. I can't believe that Kevin wasn't even in the bottom 3. I just can't believe that at this level others are leaving before him. I was shocked that Ace was in the bottom three. I had the feeling that every one liked him.

I have quite a few favorites and it is just going to kill me when one of them has to go. At this point I hate seeing any one get kicked off though. I just hate seeing the hurt on their faces. Although, I think I could handle it ok if it were to be Kevin next week...lol

[Lobodeb]

I have to agree with Robin. I liked Melissa and I loved her voice. Kevin should have gone long before her, but I knew she was a longshot. I totally disagree with the bottom 3. Lisa Tucker? That girl could sing the phone book. I think it was the arrangement of her song that I didn't like. How many times could she say, "signed sealed delivered?"

[rosethecopycat]

I think it was the arrangement of her song that I didn't like. How many times could she say, "signed sealed delivered?"

Exactly. That was a weak song. We were worried about her, and when she got called out, I thought my husband was going to be right, for once.

But, they crucified Melissa for breaking the cardinal rule, as I suspected.

[anna_66]

I have to say I'm very surprised about the bottom 3 and even more surprised that Melissa was the one who ended up leaving. I really loved her voice.

[beeniesmom]

I knew Melissa was going to go.... were you guys really that surprised?

I think Kevin is next and then Lisa.

I was not surprised to see Ace in the bottom 3.

Someone had to be there. It could have been anyone.

I think our top 3 are:

Chris
Katherine
Taylor

[pitc9]

I think our top 3 are:

Chris
Katherine
Taylor

I agree 100%!! Those are going to be the last three left in the end!!