American Idol Season 5

**rosethecopycat** · 03-04-2006, 08:59 AM

I watched my TIVO a bit late.so, here it comes...

Obscene.

Sway was a much better vocalist than: Will (Peter Brady), Kevin, Bucky.

Additionally, I think Sway should have lasted longer than Ace, and possibly Gedeon.

Sway should have gotten 4th place, behind Chris, Elliot, Taylor.

Hands down. Sway sang a very challenging Stevie song and what does Peter Brady sing? Kenny Rogers? give me a break.
Sorry folks, Kevin may be cute but he does NOT have a very good instrument. His range is limited, he has not demonstated falsetto range, and he doesn't have any dynamic power (belt notes). In addition, his voice does not have a clear tone. I have no idea why he is still there.
Bucky, it sounds like you smoke 3 packs of Camels right before your sing. Getting tired of it.

By the way, Elliot sang a song that was absolutely phenonemal. Vocal gymnastics!

Taylor, you need to 'step it up' quickly now. You've got that raw soul, but you need to pick the right songs, or the other two guys are going to roll right over you.

Girls: I'm going with Mandisa now.

**Lobodeb** · 03-09-2006, 07:03 PM

Any predictions on who's getting the boot?

If it were up to me, I'd say for the ladies, Kinnik and Ayla.

From the guys, Will and Kevin.

What do you all think?

**k9krazee** · 03-09-2006, 07:11 PM

Not sure about the girls, I haven't really been watching them

The guys...I really like Will, I don't want to see him go but he probably will. I also think its time for Kevin to leave, or possibly Bucky...

**Felix** · 03-09-2006, 08:51 PM

When American Idol first began I made this.My top 6 pix

I LOVE Chris for the boys(He's a HOTTIE )

I like Katharine for the girls

I think these two will go far in this competition.

**prechrswife** · 03-09-2006, 09:13 PM

So, what does everyone think about the top 12? I was a little surprised that Gedeon and Ayla did not make it, and that Kevin and Melissa did. Overall, though, it looks like this should be a good competition.

**Lobodeb** · 03-09-2006, 10:27 PM

I had 3 out of 4 right. I'm sorry, but I don't like Kevin. Something just rubs me wrong with him. I predicted (not here) all 6 girls and 5 of the guys. I, for once, agreed with Simon when he said that Kevin's performance last night was juvenille. It sounded, to me, like a kid at his school play. Oh well.

Let's hear it for the top 12!!!!!