Letters Left:
B C F H J M P Q U V X Z

Dog -oke
An Easterner w-o walked into a Western saloon was
a-a-ed to see a dog sitting at a ta-le -laying -oker wit-
t-ree -en.
"-an t-at dog really read -ards?" -e asked.
"Yea-, --t -e ain't ---- o- a -layer," said one o- t-e -en.
"W-ene-er -e gets a good -and -e wags -is tail."
~-nknown A-t-or

Thanks Casperandkitty, there were a few letters missing.

I really messed up on the points, due to some missing letters.
Here's a recap:

Momoffuzzyfaces - 12(S) = 12 pts
Fuzzy 317- 30(E) +16(N) +18(T) = 94pts
Cutie Chica - 29(A) + 7(L) + 17(O) = 99pts
Rottieluver45 - 11(D) + 9(I)= 29pts
Casper&Kitty - 8(G) + 8(W) + 5(K)= 21 pts
Ann - 11(R) + 4(Y) = 19pts