Josie Wants Nutro Too! *Waaaahhhh*

[Tubby & Peanut's Mom]

It would be so much easier to feed them both the same thing.

Unfortunately I can't help with the Nutro, but I just had to chime in because I'm dealing with a simliar situation. CJ is doing well on the Science Diet Z/D and is finally starting to produce tootsie rolls (after over a year of trying everything under the sun!), but Peanut HATES the Z/D and won't eat it unless absolutely positively necessary! I picked her up the other day and she is light as a feather and seems to have lost weight since bringing the Z/D into the house - and she does not need to loose weight! Right now we're separting them because we're having some painting done, so CJ gets one bedroom and bathroom and Peanut gets the other. Because of this, I put some regular food in her bowl this morning and she practically inhaled it! So once the painting is done and they're both back to free roaming, how in the world do I feed her regular food and CJ the Z/D? I know I can do it, and I'll have to because I can't have Peanut wasting away to nothing just because CJ has allergies, but I've free fed my cats for almost 20 years now and it's going to be a tough habit to break -for me!

Sorry about not offering any advice about your problem and ranting and raving about mine.....

[catmandu]

Its a Toss Up here.
Some Love The Science Diet Chicken and Rice.
Some love the Nutro Copmlete Care Indoor Series.
Some love the New Iams Indoor Mature.
All are premium foods and I would say give the Nutro a chance.