I like the second ring better, ONLY because I love silver & can't stand gold. BUT I like the layout of the first ring better (the stones & the way they are set).

I'm a little bit on the tomboyish side too, low key & low mantience & I would wear either one.



Garnet is my birthstone too & let me tell you what, I have the hardest time finding anything that I like that is silver or white gold with a garnet in it. I hate that. I'd love to get a nice silver/white gold garnet ring.