Thank you. Rachel, hes a border collie. Hes so skinny too...he's always been though. I don't know how I'm suppost to feel its the right time. In a way I do, I think, but the other I'm confused. I only want whats best for him. I would ask my Vet what she thinks, but I know thats not really a fair question to ask her. My mom seems to think it's time, but my bro doesn't. We give him asprin sometimes..does that help his pain? Or does he still hurt? Wow..this is so hard..I don't think, even when it is his time, that I can take him to the vets..I know I'll start to ball right infront of the vet as he/she does it..and I don't think I could look at him as he slowly fades away..I'll feel like im killing him..I guess technically I am, but I don't want it not to be his time, and I don't want to wait till his in so much pain he can't take it..I want my bro to make choice, but I'm pretty sure he'll keep waiting...I wish I could show you a video chip on him or something and get your advise. Does this sound stupid?? I'm sorry if it does..I have this big lump in my throat...