Hmmm.....interesting.....Cj is so picky that he took one sniff and walked away, but what was surprising to me was that my little piggy girl - yes, Peanut is a little piggy - also turned up her nose. Between the two of them I couldn't even get rid of one "slice"! I ended up donating them to a local rescue group, along with some other things that have been laying around the house unused - like some extra scoops, how I ended up with about 8 of them I'll never know!