No, in the second picture you can definently see that she is NOT a red roan. She is definently a Chestnut. I am very educated in horse too, and I now for sure that she is a Chestnut, so Kari, we have to give YOU the credit, you were right all along!

-edit- Her mane and tail arent black though are they? Because then she would be a bay . See, this horse stuff is complicated