I definitely think it should just be a fall thing, that way you can decide if you want to specify a holiday (halloween or thanksgiving)...or if you just want to go with the general fall look. Halloween is so specific. I think an autumn theme would enable more people to participate, and, make the contest more interesting. I've never really liked the whole photoshoot thing, but, I think I got a couple that are cute of Finn. I'd offer to host the contest, but, I wouldn't know where to start, and, I am not going to have much time here by the end of the week! I hope kfamr or someone else can host it, I think it will be fun!