You are doing what you think is best Amy and that is what counts.
Personally I would probably leave Cincy on what she's on b/c I know you have had so much trouble finding something to agree with her.
You are lucky that you Live in a large City that you have tons and tons of options. Keegan and I aren't that lucky!
Good to know about the Science Diet Lite - if I don't switch her to Go - I might just do that until she loses her weight.
I subscribe to whole dog journal. http://www.whole-dog-journal.com/ I don't think you can check back issues without ordering them but they do extensive research on dog foods. I will pull my copies of all the dog food related stuff and copy them for you and send them to you.
May take until the end of the week tho - there is a lot of stuff!
My Vet sells Science Diet also of course - which is why I was intrigued when going to this new vet and she sells Go.
My best friend's husband is a Vet also and as much as I love them they feed their dogs Purina One also I just kind of wrinkled my nose in distaste after my experience.
I remember now that your pups were on Sensible Choice by Royal Canin. (duh - Stace) I fell in love with the holistic blend when I had Shaianne b/c anything I fed her she got gastritis from I tried this and she did fabulous on it until she passed away.
Good luck.