I am the odd man out here. I won't give them to my girls at all. They used to get them when they were little then I found out they contain BHA/BHT as a preservative. I found out that BHA/BHT can cause certain cancers in cats. So, I stopped giving them to my girls. They now get Nutro MaxCat Gourmet Kitty crunchy cat treats and they go gaga for them. They love them just as much as Temptations. I was sooo surprised because they are super fussy. I know they are double the price of the Temptations but for my own peace of mine I would rather give them these than the others and they don't object one little bit. I just have to shake the bag and they come a runnin' and talking. LOL