I think so too Randi!

Casper & Kitty:
7 E's = 14 points
1 I = 2 points
0 K's = 0 points
3 C's = 3 points
2 F's = 2 points
1 Y = 1 point
Total points = 22


Randi:
8 A's = 16 points
4 O's = 8 points
3 N's = 3 points
2 R's = 2 points
8 T's = 8 points
6 S's = 6 points
Total points = 35


delidog:
3 U's = 6 points
Total points = 6


Puzzle:

Cats are s-arte- t-an -o-s. You can't -e- ei--t cats to -u-- a s-e- t-r-u-- sno-. ~ -eff -a--e-

Available Letters:

BDGHJLMPQVWXZ