Casper & Kitty:
7 E's = 14 points
Total points = 14


Randi:
8 A's = 16 points
Total points = 16


Puzzle:

-a-- a-e --a--e- --a- ----. --- -a-'- -e- e---- -a-- -- ---- a --e- ------- ----. ~ -e-- -a--e-

Available Letters:

BCDFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ