Hmmm... could be both...I'm sure she wouldn't have had any complaints if we had that Dim Sum seafood...But it's just a box from a shop, no treats, had to carry my shoppings with it... Left it on the floor and got Kitty in it. Typical... Funny though, they have been biting that box really badly, had to take it away, maybe that Dim Sum was still smelling in it...