that is a toughy then. try old socks tied up into a ball. he will tear it up and you really haven't lost anything. Yours doesn't like peanut butter???? wow. mine loves it. i like beagles by the way. first dog i had was a beagle. He was running wild in the neighborhood and noone could catch him. He was pretty smart. he could steal food off a grill and take off for the hills. Everyone wanted him but he only liked me. Daddy caught him in a box trap and we tamed him with hotdogs. i sure loved that dog. I was only about 5 or so