Here's The Puzzle:

A ---'s ------i-i--a- ---e -a- s-i---a-e ---- i----e s-s-e-, ---e- -----
--ess--e a-- ----es-e--- a-- -e-- -a-- --- -e--essi--.

--- -a--- -a-e--a-

Letter to pick from:

BCDFGHJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ

There are 10 A's
There are 13 E's
There are 5 I's
There are 9 S's

Randi has 26+10=36 points
Daisylover has 20 points
Momoffuzzyfaces has 9 points