LOL I'm the last person to ask about putting cats on diets. Shadow is 14 lbs. and Callie is 13 lbs. Whisper is actually the dainty one of 11 lbs and he doesn't have an ounce of fat on him--he's all fur. Callie gets table scraps (she's the only one who begs relentlessly aka puts her paw/tongue on my food ) and they are fed twice a day about two cups in total.

I think Puff is absolutely adorable. The only person's who opinion really counts would be a vet. If a vet says to put her on a diet, then I would.

Whisper sends his love to her Puffiness!