That's the way my babies are too! Santa brought them the BEST toy ever....complete with squeeker and enclosed jingly bell. They LOVED it when it was hanging off of mommy, but when mommy hung it off the door, it merely became a decoration on the cat room door. Sigh....these funny little furries. The have TONS of toys but only play with a few.

My cats arent allowed to have little mice though....I'll give them one and find it an hour later with no eyes, ears or tail. If I find it later than that (which I have) it'll be without fur! And I've never found the outside of the mice....i guess they had a yummy mouse outfit meal.