You know 20/20 hindsight is a beautiful thing. We had planned to get Tobey chipped and like everything else we put it off and didn't do it and if we had there wouldn't have been a question as to whom the dog belonged. We are planning on fighting it in small claims court, but it makes me angry that we were told that he was ours and that when we found him we could have him back with all the records we have and now they're saying no we can't. We are going to contact the contractor whose men saw Tobey and the guy chasing him and get notarized statements from them testifying to what they saw. The girl at animal control told us also to force him to show vet records for him being neutered (which he won't be able to do) and nail him that way.