"He may just not be hungry. When did you get him? Do you know when his last feeding was? Are you feeding a live or a dead pinky? Do you know what he was used to eating before you got him? Is he warm enough?

My snakes eat better in the morning or afternoon then they do at night, maybe you should try again tomorrow.

If the pinky is dead and it's been sitting for a couple hours then you should throw it out.

Please don't get yourself too worked up about it."

Thank you so much. I got him last Saturday. 11/18 (If that was Saturday..lol) His last feeding was last Wednesday. They feed their snakes every Wednesday, that's when they get their pinkys in. The pinky is alive, we are going to try to switch him to frozen. His feeding tank IS heated, I will check how warm it is in a little bit.
One of my main concerns is for the pinky, too. What do I do with him if he doesn't get eaten, and is still alive by tomorrow? I just don't want him to suffer.