I've been feeding Precise dry since last winter (on the advice of the lady at the pet food store) and they really like it - but Abby has become such a little butterball on it. I think Hanna is getting a little plumper too (but that could be because she isn't a kitten anymore). I've been thinking about switching to Nutro. I need to put weight on Bo (I pick him up from his I-131 tonight! Yaya! I can't wait) but the two girls might need some sort of lite fomula. I really like the convenience of feeding all three cats the same dry food, though.