I too, honestly, think it was rude of the manager to stop them........as long as they never had set limits, I don't think that was right. I still found the story funny. What a scene made over something as simple as roast beef! *still wondering how someone on a diet could eat 12 pieces* They must have REALLY enjoyed the meal. He he...........Really, I don't think I'm on either one's side. I thought the manager was rude.........then I thought the consumers were going way overboard in the amount of food they ate too.