@cassiesmom - um, nope. Freckles, I overlooked an S and added it and upped your score. My bad!

A baby -s G-d's -p-n--n that l-f- sh--ld g- -n.

~ Carl S-ndb-rg

Letters to guess:

E IJK OPQ UVWX Z

Karen: 2 Ts, 3 Ds, 4 As, 1 P, 3 Bs = 17
Felicia's Mom: 4 Ns, 1 Y (as a vowel) = 6
cassiesmom: 1 C, 3 Ls, 1 H, 3 Gs = 8
mrspunkysmom: 2 Hs = 2
Asiel: 2 Rs = 2
Freckles: 4 Ss = 4