Pinot will, on occasion, tell us her bathroom is below standard and poop in the middle of the oriental (in the downstairs rec room where her box is). She will also poop where ever she is (downstairs usually) if she's not well. It seems you have at least one of these situations with your kitty. I don't know the condition of the box, but the kitty has not been feeling well and sometimes they can't control where they go (especially if there is a loose stool situation). If she has all health problems clear and the box is cleaned on a regular basis, by all means, give her another one.