Yup, I feed my cats TOTW as well. Have done for several years now and very pleased with it!

In general, I agree with you about the Rx foods.

Friend of mine has 2 bichons, and one girl has had bladder stones and needed surgery - TWICE in just 8 months! Because, after the first surgery, she did lots of on line research, read the label on the Rx diet, and tried to duplicate it without the "bad" stuff. After the second surgery - and she felt awful, as if she caused her dog to go through that a 2d time -- she capitulated and now uses the Rx diet. She also uses cranberry pills -- prescribed by the doc as well, I believe -- and has the urine tested once a month, to attempt to catch anything more quickly. Sorry, don't remember which end of the pH scale the dog's stones were at (yup it does matter). I can find out, if you want.

Anyway, good luck with Skinny!

I had my dogs on TOTW for almost a year, but Lacey kept having low blood glucose episodes, so I switched to Halo Spot's Stew. The lamb formula made Sugar itch like mad, but the chicken formula is working for all 5 pups. SO much trial and error with foods.