My boys like dthe dry Chicken Soup For the Cat Lover's Soul the one time I gave it to them, but they HATED the canned. It is very liquidy, almost like soup, and they wouldn't touch it. I think this is a great food and I sooo wanted them to like it, but they didn't. I hope you have more luck with it. I feed Blue Wilderness dry and wet mostly, but my boys seem to like the Wellness canned a bit more. Well, this weekend I am taking my cans back and asking them if they have any "safe" Wellness. This is SUCH a good food and Mac and Ming both love it!