I switched to BLUE from Innova (which was good) recently and my kitties love it. They actually eat the food and not just the gravy. I use the dry and occasionally some canned. I do feed MaxCat canned. small ones, and the cats like that too. I do not use MaxCat dry foods. I recently switched from Fancy Feast canned food, which was causing problems. The critters were also finicky about which flavors. They were trying to tell me something.

I use BLUE Buffalo and Wilderness. They have not expressed a preference except mine like Chicken. Don't know why. They will even eat the canned chicken with no dietary complaints. It appears that all dietary issues have been resolved since the switch.

I buy Blue Kitten for a local cat rescue and have received no complaints. The Store manager that runs the rescue insists that new purrents feed the cats with Blue, Eagle Pack, or Wellness.

Good Luck