Lorraine, my RB Puddy had the exact same problem except I somehow managed to clip that claw w/out causing any pain. Don't ask me how because, if you'll recall, Puddy was a handful! I would've had the claw removed in a heartbeat if my vet had suggested it. In this case, it's the right thing to do for Lindy Lou. She'll have PT prayers as her backup, so no worries there. Keep the faythe and dry those tears. She'll be fine.