I had an idea while getting ready for work today. What if you put the new fountain you purchased for Puddy in the tub? I know you already leave the sink faucet running but since she is still insisting that the tub faucet be turned on, maybe this would be a temporary solution. I know she gave the fountain a thumbs down the first time but maybe she will accept it rather than no water at all in the tub. It might be too kookie of an idea though. lol