There ARE a lot of black cats floating around...perhaps Tubster was framed?

One time, the neighbors complained about a black cat prowling around their house and just assumed it was Spook even though I didn't let her outside and there were at least three other black cats living around the neighborhood. I'd be on the lookout for some other black kitties, to see if your boy is innocent as the neighbors will probibly still complain even if you keep Tubster inside.