Quote Originally Posted by Sighthounds4me View Post
First of all, I see nothing wrong with Diamond. We fed it for years, and did fine. It's actually a pretty good food for a low price, if you are on a budget.

However, since the formula is changing, I can see the concern. But I'd still give it a chance, and see what happens.

But I also do not like Bil-Jac much. They use inferior quality ingredients, IMHO, and the fact that they use corn and soy in a lot if their formulations bothers me.

I do, however, like Fromm, if you can find it. The Four-Star line is the best, but not very cheap. Their regular stuff isn't too bad, either.

We are currently feeding American Natural Premium www.americannaturalpremium.com. It's actually a contract food by Fromm, and is a fantastic food, ant a VERY good price.

But I'd also look at Innova, Eagle Pack, California Natural, Solid Gold (though it is sold in Petco now, so time will tell what that does to the quality).

By the way, here is a good article that can help you look at the labels, and interpret what you read...
I agree; Diamond was the first food I ever fed my dogs and my only concern was that Charlie had THE SMELLIEST gas on that food... whoooo boy could he clear a HOUSE!

Some of Diamond's foods aren't that great, but some of their formulas are really very good (in my opinion).

The only concern of mine that I may have is the change in formula and how it will affect my dog's tummys, etc. I will look into this further however and see HOW they are changing the formula and maybe look into feeding other alternative foods. But until then, it doesn't alarm me at all.

Also, solely in my opinion of course, Diamond is better than Bil Jac.