I think getting a shelter dog would be a great idea. You can get one that is a little older - like a year that is already house trained. We got Dazzi from a friend who gave her to us when he got divorced and was moving to an apartment. He had got her from the shelter when she was about a year old. She is the best trained dog! She comes when you call, she doesn't leave the yard except for a little wandering and comes back the moment you call her name even in mid bunny chase, was house trained, rides well in the car, and in general is a great dog. We didn't have to deal with chewing, or any of the other things you have to deal with with puppies. I would think in Columbus you would have a great choice of dogs of all ages and types. Good luck in whatever you decide!