mrspunky'smom submitted a correct answer but does not wish to host the next puzzle. Catty1 submitted an incorrect answer. So, I'm leaving it open a while longer to see if anyone else can get it!

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

E-tract -rom ‘The Stealing o- the Mare’

The gre- mare the reno-ne-, in the -orl- there is none li-e her…

S-are is her hea- an- lean; her ears -ric-e- close together;

Her -oreloc- is a net, her -orehea- a lam- li-hte-

Ill-minating the tri-e; her nec- c-rve- li-e a -alm -ranch

Her -ither clean an- shar-… her -orelegs are t-in lances,

Her hooves -l- -or-ar- -aster ever than -lies the -hirl-in-,

Her tail~-one hel- alo-t, -et the hairs s-ee- the gravel.

A--~-e--

wombat2u2004: 65 Es = 130 pts
Randi: 30 As + 32 Hs + 19 Ns= 111 pts
Maltese_Love: 20 Is = 40 pts
Killearn Kitties: 26 Ts + 9 Cs + 22 Ls + 4 Vs = 61 pts
Catty1: 16 Os + 38 Rs = 70 pts
Karen: 15 Ss + 6 Ms = 21 pts
mrspunky'smom: 6 Gs = 6 pts

BDFJKPQUWXYZ