Looks pretty good. Actually, it reminds me of the Red Barn rolls. However, I would only use it as a supplement. With so much animal protein, too, I wonder why the protein % is only 10%. I also don't like the soy flour or the salt or the brewers rice. But, I have to admit, they'd be greyt training treats They say they're not affected by the recall, and it's very generous of them to donate! I say go for it, but be sure the food rolls have not expired =)