I guess Bob`s favourite place to be is in his crate, at least that is where he tend to end up. Other times hes just lying around on the floor somewhere. I never really trained him not to get on the furniture, he just doesn`t, never really tried to, even when he was a pup. Other dogs I have had did get up on the chairs, sofas and beds, but maybe because Bob was crated from the very first day I had him is the reason he doesn`t, and also why he now regards his crate as his `den` and goes to it a lot.
Having said all that a couple of months ago he began getting on the sofa to look through the window, like as though he just discovered he could. It was/is very odd. Anyway, I don`t stop him, he seems to enjoy looking our so much He doesn`t lie on there or anything, once he`s had enough of looking out he gets back down on the floor. Though it can be a bit of a pain when Im sitting on there too and he sees something interesting and starts doing a `dance`with his two back legs with his tail swishing in my face! LOL.