Quote Originally Posted by Muddy4paws
Its a shame hes being put to sleep, It sounds to me that hes got some huge trust issues with both of you and having a unstable enviroment isn't helping at all.

He needs professional help and if you cant provide it for him I think you should find someone who can instead of ending his life, Fair enough you didnt know what issues he had when you took him on but now you do and now is the chance to pass him to someone with more experience than youself who can deal with his issues. I think having him put to sleep is the easy way out to be honest.
We cannot just rehome him. He MUST be returned to the shelter. & not only that, but Bear HAS to go back with him... Since both dogs have been returned before, they both will be PTS... If I just return Mr. Biggles & tell him he attacked someone, he'll be PTS.

Lets see my options...
1. Loose both dogs & have them die alone
2. Return Mr. Biggles to them telling them he attacked someone & having him die alone in a scary place.
OR
3. Having him PTS with me there comforting him.

I still see 3 as being the best option. I don't care what he did, i can't just let him die alone, thats not right.