No, Liz, give him a chance. Don't think like that. Don't give up hope. It may not be over yet. Wait, see what the vet says. I know the whine you are talking about. I heard it with my GSD Wolf with hip dysplasia. I heard it with Avalanche's ACL rupture. I know how you feel about hearing them in pain. It is gut-wrenching, but still, he may recover. Think positive thoughts. We are praying for a miracle here. Miracles have happened here before and we are praying for another. Don't give up. We are with you.