I thought Elliot sang "Moody's Mood for Love" extremely well. But it's the only style of song he can do! I'm not saying Katharine has nailed every single genre, but at least she doesn't sound the same all. the. time. *cough* Elliot *cough* *hack* Taylor *hack* When she just sings and doesn't try to go all diva, she has a beautiful voice. She is a much better fit for the title of Idol than Taylor. Besides the "soul patrol" (lame!), who is going to buy his records? I love blues and old classics, which seem to be his forte, and I wouldn't buy his stuff because I don't think he's anything special. Can he sing? Yes. Does he knock my socks off? No. Does Katharine? She can - "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" was proof enough of that.